Leave A Comment

Subscribe
Notify of
11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
no

While science is nice,this is science fiction. I really don’t like pushing the square cube law so hard like it has all of a sudden. As it enters nerd zeitgeist(normies wont give a shit), the next movie about giant robots will be expected to address the issue. Do we want long science explanations, or giant robots punching giant monsters? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square-cube_law If noone else has seen anything on this, I feel like every armchair physicist has come out of their dirty hole in the ground screaming “these robots cant exist because SCIENCE”, when in reality they aren’t pushing for accuracy, there… Read more »

Aquaman43

im having a problem with the difference of size between mechagodzilla and gipsy danger. i remember in the old movies, sometimes tanks were as big as one of MG’s toes. hm. i want to drink scotch and talk about this in a dim room lined with comic long boxes and posters of witchblade.

guest

[From the Wiki page] “When a physical object maintains the same density and is scaled up, its mass is increased by the cube of the multiplier while its surface area only increases by the square of said multiplier.” The kick is, of course, that there’s no reason to maintain the density when scaling up a robot. There’s a reason why this law doesn’t quite apply to airplanes (they’re mostly empty inside). And giant robots should work the same way. My biggest problem with credibility is with using the human shape as a basis for the giant robot. Star Wars had… Read more »

Sixten

Signed

flood123

You are correct. Though cool, a human shaped robot serves little if any purpose. The profile on these things are huge. For military applications it makes little sense because it’s a LARGE target. Another hurdle is powering one of these things. The amount of energy that would be required to power one giant robot would be enormous. All I can imagine at this point would be a nuclear reactor like the type you would find in a submarine. Imagine how unstable that might be, The amount of armor required to protect that nuclear core would be insane. Now on a… Read more »

Aquaman43

yes. i think one of the jaegers from pacific rim had a nuclear reactor in it. crimson typhoon maybe? and the russian one, cherno alpha, had a shit load of armor, but the acid spray from a monster kicked its ass anyway.

no

They all had “unspecified” nuclear reactors. Gypsy had a “oldschool” “analog” main nuclear, and a huge amount of diesel engines in the limbs..

JediaKyrol

I think the one of the few times the decision to make giant robots made any sense was in Macross…Humans found remains of 7 meter tall humanoids and their powered-armor space-suits, then adapted it to a robot suit. This insured that if they had to perform combat operations inside enemy ships/facilities they would be able to maneuver more easily. Then they got silly and made some of the robots turn into planes and re-rigged a 3-mile long ship to also turn into a giant robot because when you find alien super tech, why not go overboard.

Sixten

Always thought this was an elegant solution.

faithless

It saddens me sometimes when I am reminded that the internet is full of morons.

The machines in Pacific rim are NOT robots. They can be called a number of things, but direct control by a human means they aren’t self-actuated and therefore not robots.

They are like super-versions of the loader that Ripley drives in Aliens, and I think of them as ‘waldoes’.

JediaKyrol

It saddens ME sometimes when I am reminded that the internet is full of morons! waldo [?w??ld??] n pl -dos, -does (Engineering / Tools) a gadget for manipulating objects by remote control [named after Waldo F. Jones, inventor in a science-fiction story by Robert Heinlein] ro·bot [roh-buht, -bot] noun 1. a machine that resembles a human and does mechanical, routine tasks on command. 2. a person who acts and responds in a mechanical, routine manner, usually subject to another’s will. 3. any machine or mechanical device that operates automatically with humanlike skill. adjective 4. operating automatically: a robot train operating… Read more »