MP3 Ratings?

Dear MCS:

I’d been using winamp for years upon years, and it’s been great. I just recently found out that if you move your music collect from folder X to folder Y, you lose all your ratings information, and you will never get it back.   So, I tried Media Monkey, which according to my google-fu is the only mp3 player that stores the ratings in the file itself, and not in some arbitrary xml file that get deleted everytime you sneeze.

However, I’m having trouble using MM, as it likes to just max out my cpu at 100%, and the music starts to stutter like a mother fucker.   THIS is annoying to say the least.   So, a litte more google-fu and everyone is raving about foobar2000. only problem? no support for file ratings afaik.

So tell me. How can I have a mp3 collection of over 40 gigs, and have the ratings in the files?   Is it really so much to ask? And please, no itunes, that shit is satan.

Also, I’d love to be able to sync the songs that are top rated / top played to a usb drive, so I can play them in my truck.

Send to Facebook | Send To Twitter
  • Twitch


  • Leave A Comment

    Notify of
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments

    I don’t even rate my music. I just let it play in shuffle and random. If I want a certain music genre or artist I’ll just type it in the search box of Winamp.

    If there are tracks that have a low rating for you, which is apparently what’s so important for you, why keep them at all?

    Not trying to be an ass, just asking.


    I rate my music, but then again I have a “sophisticated” rating system that goes beyond the typical use of ratings…

    5 stars = top priority to listen to
    4 = I’ve listened to it extensively and I enjoyed it
    3 stars = haven’t listened extensively and rated it yet
    2 = I’ve listened to it extensively and I didn’t enjoy it
    1 star = NA
    0 stars = nonmusical, or some kind of miscellaneous collection in which it wouldn’t make sense to rate the songs as one collective entity

    Yeah, weird…

    Anyways, I don’t use anything to encode the ratings as part of the files.

    That’s why I had to start over again when my iTunes arbitrarily decided to erase my files from the library…

    [/no one cares]


    Understood. In my case if I play a good song one too many times, it becomes average. That’s why ratings are not cut out for me. And my collection’s considerably small compared to others, it’s around 1500 MP3’s.


    Yeah…I’ve got 22,929 MP3’s (really AAC’s) so rating helps to organize and prioritize…


    DAMN! you win… I only have about 17,260 mp3s, lol.

    Almost all of mine are metal and hard rock.


    Heh, guess I shouldn’t mention the additional 3,957 mp3s in my miscellaneous non-iTunes folder. ^_^

    Anyways, as for genre, since I took the time to organize ’em, I might as well share:

    50s/60s/70s = 723
    Alternative = 2388
    Folk/Country/Blues-rock/Jam (includes blues) = 615
    Anime (don’t watch, do listen) = 545
    Classical guitar = 64
    Com/prac: Chamber (classical) = 58
    Com/prac: Orchestral (classical) = 420
    Com/prac: Solo (classical) = 237
    Com/prac: Vocal (classical) = 172
    Contemporary classical = 298
    Darkwave/Medieval = 247
    Electronic = 497
    Film score = 2252
    Hip hop = 786
    Indian (classical and popular) = 656
    Indie/Post-punk = 397
    J-Pop (yeah…) = 1003
    J-Rock = 799
    Jazz/fusion (that is, jazz *and* fusion) = 559
    Latin (includes tango, fado, etc) = 284
    Metal = 688
    Musical = 319
    Opera = 618
    “Other” = 971
    Post-rock = 99
    Power pop/-punk = 594
    Progressive = 327
    Punk/Ska/Reggae = 276
    R&B/Soul/Funk = 188
    Regional (popular music from non-Anglo countries) = 889
    World (traditional music from non-Anglo countries) = 551

    Hopefully you can decipher some of the abbreviations and musicologist jargon… As for the bizarre genre combos, that’s just how I saw most effective to organize my library. ^_^

    Anyways, that was a wonderful way to waste 7 minutes. =/


    hope its helpful.


    This is what I do, and it works great for me.

    As irkusk mentioned, mp3s have metadata attached to them. One of the fields available is “comment”. I don’t know about WinAmp, but iTunes allows you to search, filter, and modify comments of each of your files.

    The comment of one of my mp3s would look something like this:

    energetic, montage, 4

    where “energetic” and “montage” are my personal tags for the file, and 4 is my personal rating.

    I then set up smart playlists that contain only files with certain tags in the comments section. This way, I can transfer my whole collection of songs, search by comment:4, add a star rating of 4 for those files, and I’m done recovering my star rating. Smart playlists are transferrable, but even if they weren’t, they only take a few seconds to create from scratch.

    If WinAmp has a way to bulk modify, filter, and search the comments field, this will work for you, too!


    Yeah, you can have Smart Playlists organize by comment/grouping/whatever. Just see which tags are actually part of the file, and use those.


    I use a combination of Winamp and MediaMonkey for my music – MediaMonkey tags the album art and rating into the mp3 and is great for bulk renaming of the file, but I prefer to use Winamp to actually play the song. You just have to watch out, since when you mess with the tag in MediaMonkey, the year and comment tag is screwed up (no matter what you’re editing) in Winamp.


    Tiki: What you seek is doable in Foobar. The easiest way I know of doing it is to download the Quick Tagger plugin, which lets you set tags to predefined values from the right click menu. Then you just set up a tag called Rating, and set it’s values to 1,2,3,4,5 or A,B,C,D or whatever, then you can easily rate the songs, and though I haven’t fiddled with it much, it’s apparently pretty simple to set up playlists based on tag values.


    Try MP3Toys. I like it a lot!


    Can’t you just not move your files?


    WMP10, Playlist, “favs”

    Who uses the rating system anyways? :\

    Plus it comes with windows…

  • Here's a few awesome images!