Fake. On a standard double-spaced page using Times New Roman at 12pt, written in MLA format—as this one is, minus the header and the date’s in the wrong place—you can write 16-18 lines after the title line. This one has 25 lines after the title, so whoever Photoshopped this was lacking some details. Also, what printer would print a page with left-hand margins like that, especially in 1999? And most high school teachers don’t write like they’re 10 years old, and the trend is to avoid red ink.